Cost estimate exceeded: who pays
A client who commissions the shell of a building or a renovation usually receives a cost estimate from the contractor. If the final invoice is higher, the question is whether the additional amount has to be paid and whether the contractor was required to warn the client in time. In decision 6 Ob 90/26t of 29 September 2026 the Austrian Supreme Court (OGH) held that the overrun is to be measured against the full offer price. It did not regard an overrun of about 8 % as considerable. The contractor therefore did not have to give notice of it, and the clients had to pay it.
The case
Two clients commissioned a building contractor to erect the shell of their single-family house. The contract was based on an offer of October 2021 for 197,551.09 euros including VAT. According to the offer, prices were variable and the stated hours and quantities of material were approximate; the works were to be invoiced on the basis of actual expenditure.
The contractor's invoices finally amounted to 255,133.04 euros. This included 39,600 euros for removing the excavated soil. The parties had agreed that the soil would be stored on the clients' plot or on the neighbouring plot. Shortly before the works began it turned out that this was not possible. An employee of the contractor estimated that about 40 lorry loads would be needed; in fact there were more than 110. There was also a chimney costing 2,186.89 euros, which the clients had ordered as an addition while the works were in progress. The contractor did not carry out certain items of the offer worth 18,184.97 euros and did not invoice them either.
The clients left part of the invoices unpaid. The contractor sued for the outstanding remuneration of 41,362.01 euros. The clients objected that the contractor had not warned them of the overrun in time. They also alleged defects.
What the law says about cost estimates
Austrian law distinguishes two kinds of cost estimate. Where the contractor has expressly guaranteed that the estimate is correct, it cannot demand higher remuneration even if unforeseen additional work arises (§ 1170a Abs 1 ABGB). Where the client is a consumer, the estimate is deemed to be guaranteed as correct unless the contractor has expressly declared the contrary (§ 5 Abs 2 KSchG, the Consumer Protection Act). In this case it was no longer in dispute before the Supreme Court that the contract was based on a cost estimate without a guarantee.
A cost estimate without a guarantee is governed by § 1170a Abs 2 ABGB. Where a considerable overrun proves unavoidable, the contractor must notify the client without delay. If it fails to do so, it loses any claim for the additional work. In the event of such an overrun the client may withdraw from the contract; the client must pay reasonable remuneration for the work already performed. According to the decision, the client has to accept overruns that are not considerable and cannot be avoided.
The statute does not say at what point an overrun is considerable. In earlier decisions the Supreme Court treated 14 % and 30 % of the total remuneration as considerable (7 Ob 514/82, 8 Ob 521/93). The comparison is made on the basis of the total remuneration, because the final sum is what matters to the client.
The decision
The court of appeal had deducted the items that were not carried out from the offer price and had therefore compared the invoice with 179,366.12 euros. The Supreme Court rejected this approach. According to its reasoning, the question is how far the total cost originally forecast has proved to be incorrect; deducting items that were not carried out would distort that yardstick. The basis of comparison is therefore the full offer price.
Additional costs resulting from changes to the works and from additional orders are left out of the comparison. Like the court of appeal, the Supreme Court therefore deducted the cost of removing the excavated soil and the cost of the chimney from the invoiced total. That left 213,346.15 euros, which is about 8 % more than estimated. The Supreme Court did not regard this overrun as considerable. The contractor therefore did not have to give notice of it, and the clients have to bear it.
The Supreme Court did not treat the employee's figure of 40 lorry loads as a separate cost estimate. The employee had stated only a number and no price. The courts had also not found that the clients relied on a particular cost limit because of that figure. According to the findings, they were aware that every load would cost extra.
The Supreme Court restored the judgment of the court of first instance. That court had held the claim for remuneration to be justified in the amount of 36,862.01 euros, had accepted a claim of the clients for defects, raised by way of set-off, in the amount of 2,887.70 euros and had awarded the contractor 33,974.31 euros. The Supreme Court did not examine whether the additional costs could have been avoided, because the clients had not maintained that objection in their appeal. It did state, however, that a contractor cannot demand higher remuneration for avoidable additional costs even where the overrun is not considerable.
Consequences for clients and contractors
For clients: a cost estimate is an upper limit only if it is guaranteed as correct. Where the client is a consumer, it is deemed to be guaranteed as long as the contractor does not expressly declare the contrary (§ 5 Abs 2 KSchG). A client who needs cost certainty therefore needs to check before concluding the contract whether the offer excludes the guarantee. If it does, unavoidable overruns of the size seen in this case have to be paid. Additional orders and changes made during construction do not count towards the overrun and have to be paid separately. In this case that also applied to the removal of the excavated soil, which became necessary because the agreed storage on the plot was not possible.
For contractors: where the overrun is considerable, the claim to remuneration for the additional work depends on notice being given without delay. There is no general rule on where the threshold lies. In this case about 8 % was not considerable; in an earlier decision the Supreme Court treated 14 % as considerable. Once it becomes apparent that the final sum will be clearly above the estimate, notice must therefore be given without delay and in a form that can be proved. In this case the contractor had merely informed the clients by email of the current invoice total. The court of appeal did not consider that to be sufficient notice; the Supreme Court no longer had to decide the point.
For both: in this case the Supreme Court did not treat a statement that gives only a quantity and no price as a cost estimate. Anyone who wants to rely on a cost limit for an additional service needs to ask for the price and record it in writing.
This information is general in nature and does not replace legal advice on an individual case.